## International Council of English and Literature Journal (ICELJ)

Published By Delmon Publications ISSN : Applied

Review

## Review

The peer –review has the indispensable mechanism with which the quality of the research paper is judged.

#### 1. Reviewers are obliged to his/her manuscripts with lot of respect towards them.

#### 2. Authors should be informed clearly about review process.

#### 3. The editor should ensure that peer-review should be masked in both directions as such the identity of the author is removed to protect the confidentiality of the author.

#### 4. Editor has to give strict instructions to the reviewers that process should be prompt, undiscriminatory and highly professional.

#### 5. Editor has to maintain the confidentiality of the research papers which are undergoing the research process and should leave the comments and criticism.

#### 6. Editor has the prime responsibility to send the reviewers’ comments to the author(s)’promptly.

#### 7. Providing the truthful, fair, and constructive and informative critique for the submitted work.

#### 8. Reviewers should give a truthful assessment which includes strengths and weakness of the authors.

#### 9. Reviewers who agree to review the process must complete the reviews with in specific time.

#### 10. The material that is submitted for peer-review should be treated in confidence.

#### 11. The reviewers should give unbiased feedback in timely manner.

#### 12. Papers under the review process should not be shared or discussed with any other person except other reviewers.

#### 13. Every reviewer should respect the intellectuality of the each author.

#### 14. The comments that are provided by the reviewers should be based on the facts from research paper but not from personal or professional bias.

#### 15. The reviewers should not misinterpret the facts from the from original research paper.

Kindly consider the following questions when review a research paper:

#### 1. Does the title reflect the content of the submitted paper?

#### 2. Does the object give a clear view of the topic chosen?

#### 3. Does the paper speak clearly, strongly and convincingly?

#### 4. Is the paper well structured?

#### 5. Is there any irrelevant information?

#### 6. Is the paper well structured with all necessary allusions?

#### 7. Is the paper well supported with sufficient bibliographic?

#### 8. Is the conclusion supported by the content?

Copyrights For
Registered by Delmon Publications
Developed & Maintained By BVS Infotech.